Don’t fathers matter?: “Parenting” magazines

by PJ Mullen on March 27, 2009

in Don't Fathers Matter, Fatherhood Friday

A Sudden Boom in Parenting Magazines
Image by reinvented via Flickr

Mom to Mom. Woman to Woman                                                                                
- Tag line for American Baby Magazine

Straight Talk for New Moms
- Tag line for Baby Talk Magazine

“This new edition of Parenting brings you reality tested advice that’s truly relevant to your life as a mom with young kids.”                                      
- Parenting Magazine direct marketing flyer addressed to me

If you stop to think about it, these tag lines and marketing propaganda are pretty audacious. Before I got started blogging about my experiences as a father I was willing to chalk it up to them not scrubbing their marketing lists very well. After all, who would send gender specific marketing messages to the gender opposite of their target audience? Then, as I began to notice the tag lines these magazines have, I basically realized that the people in charge of writing this drivel have surmised that men either can’t or don’t read.

Now, I will admit the one good thing about their assumption that us dads can’t read is that when they publish articles like “The One Discipline Secret Every Mom Needs” in April’s Parent Magazine I can skip it.  Realistically speaking it wasn’t information that they felt was important for me to know.  So why should I fill the space in my head otherwise reserved for sports statistics and playmate of the month dimensions with knowledge that is not intended for me?  I mean, I’m just the dad.  I’m the one that is supposed to serve chocolate cake and grapefruit juice to my kids for breakfast.  I guess I should feel fortunate that they have taken the burden of defining the roles in my family from me so I can continue along in my Neanderthal ways.  

Can you sense my utter disdain for “parenting” magazines? I hope so, because I’m laying it on pretty thick. Just to be clear I don’t think “parenting” magazines suck because many have a dozen or more pages dedicated to stuff for women, not at all. In fact I think it is important that they have that type of stuff in them for mom’s that may not have the time to read the magazines they used to enjoy before they became mothers, or to provide a different perspective on those topics.

No, I hate “parenting” magazines because of what they omit, ignore or otherwise ridicule: fathers.

I bet you think you know where I’m going with this rant, right? Well, I’m about to toss you a curveball.

In the immortal words of Eric “Otter” Stratton: “We gotta take these bastards. Now we could do it with conventional weapons, but that could take years and cost millions of lives. No, I think we have to go all out. I think that this situation absolutely requires a really futile and stupid gesture be done on somebody’s part.”

“And we’re just the guys to do it!” (Thanks, Bluto!)

Do what you ask? Why start our own magazine!

That’s right, we’ll call it something obnoxious like “Raising Cain” and we’ll have cool articles on things like building tree houses and making forts in the living room out of sleeping bags. Our magazine on fatherhood will have sections on sports, fantasy leagues, cars, single malt scotch, toys for boys of all ages, and, of course, parenting and fatherhood. We also need a section on food, and not any of that girly crap with cilantro or avocado. No, our food section will just be about meat – be it grilled, ground into sausage or served raw.

It can be everything the “parenting” magazines should be, only better and without the “shiny happy people” attitude. We can bring on Bill Simmons to write a column called “The Dad Guy” and talk about how he balances his family life with his obsession for sports. The only nonsense about relationships and feelings will be written by the esteemed Dr. Denis Leary with his “Shut the F@#% Up” column to help you solve all of your personal and professional problems. And the magazine just wouldn’t be complete without our guest columnist – Mr. Chuck Norris.

We can take the foundation laid at dad-blogs.com and build from there. Just like the way ESPN begat ESPN.com, which begat ESPN the Magazine. Start it out in digital format and ultimately sell out to advertisers – you could have Pampers ads right across from Glenlivet ads.

It’s brilliant, and, no, I haven’t been drinking.

LET’S DO IT!!!

Fatherhood Friday @ dad-blogs.com

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
  • divamom
    I like the idea of a parenting magazine for Dads! You should do it...skip the raw meat though...
  • Eric
    Dude, you are brilliant. You said everything I've thought a 1000 times in my head. I hate parenting magazines because they ignore half of the whole 'parent' equation. Also, they are loaded with fluff. They recycle the same articles every six months. At least your suggestions would be interesting.
  • Caesar
    I had the same idea while sitting on the pot this morning reading "Parenting" magazine. And while I may not be a stay-home dad, I am very involved in my child's life. In fact when we had her, I knew more about babies than my wife did as a result of having nieces, nephews, etc.

    To some points below...if the magazine was all about diapers, bath toys, etc. yea - most men would lose interest. But perhaps a combination of manly topics including kids. Why is it that magazines like Maxim or Esquire never mention families. NY professionals too have kids! And what's wrong with having a centerfold of a semi-nude sex goddess, followed by a centerfold of a really cool new stroller - with reviews and specs. I think it could work.

    One of my contributions to the daddy-sphere is exploring the city with my kid. LA is huge and every weekend I hit up some new venue. I plan on taking the idea globally - where to stroll with the kid around the world. So far no time for a full website so I twitter @StrollerDayTrip to give parents (yes, moms too) ideas on where to go with their little ones.

    Keep up the good work - and if the magazine is a go - I'll gladly interview for the travel correspondent position :)
  • I've had this same conversation with my wife. Why don't they just change the name of all the current parenting magazines to Mother Magazine? There is no relevant or interesting content for dads in these mags.
  • Not sure if a Parenting Mag for guys would sell, really. I haven't paid for a glossy mag in years; not since RSS. Sure, there's a market for web ad supported content, but I just don't see guys with magazines much anymore.

    Otherwise, I like the concept.
  • Unfortunately, most "parenting" magazines are just tabloids printed on shiny paper with more diaper ads. Just visit parenting.com and you will see what I mean. I would love to see diaper ads next to liquor ads, but that's just me. Great idea - keep talking about it and maybe it will appear.
  • ciaraj
    i would so read your mag instead of a parenting mag. i have read one or two in my time, and i get bored w them really fast cos it's not like i haven't heard some of that stuff before. crikey, if babies came w manuals don't ya think we'd have given birth to the manual, too? hehe
  • Joe
    Dude, I like cilantro--wtf? Seriously, though--can I still write for you?? What is the name of this bad boy? Let's do this! Great post.
  • Rob
    I agree with you on this, Dad's need their own magazine, unless maybe we post our articles in Playboy. That way you know other dads and men would read it. Don't guys say they get Playboy for the articles. LOL. Maybe not, who knows.
  • Honestly, I don't read any parenting magazines at all. It' re-marketed drivel that anyone with any common sense doesn't need a PHd to tell them. You should come for facial and we could put our hair up and talk about it all night! (just yanking your chain, of course).
  • Great topic, it's been on my rant list for years.
  • Haha i'm in favor of the Nanny of the Month. I'd totally subscribe.
  • Hmmm, I can go on and on about this one....but...I just sit back, watch, and read what everyone else has to say....even though most could not comment for lack of experience. I dont get it though, we are amazing parents...period!
  • Eric Stratten was the inspiration for my name Otter. Quoting him makes you awesome in my book. I am all for the mag. I like the inclusion of Bill Simmons. I haven't read him in about a year but I was a religous follower for several years. Funny guy.
  • Sounds like a GREAT idea...Can I be the token gay dad and have my own "
  • Absolutely! You're in!
  • Vinnie
    I would like to invest in your new media concept!
  • Sounds good, I'll send you a prospectus!
  • Yeah, a fatherhood magazine would last for a little while, but eventually guys would lose interest if there wasn't a "Nanny of the Month" kind of like the Tool Time Girl on Home Improvement. Then that would definitely be branded as sexist and all the advertising would go away. Years later we'd find out Sports Illustrated, ESPN, Maxim and GQ were behind the plot to dismantle the Dad Magazine before it ever got legs.

    Interestingly the women who swear by these magazines seem to believe their child dropped out of the sky into their wombs. I used to manage special events for Barnes & Noble and I saw this madness first-hand on a daily basis.
  • Unfortunately, you are spot on in your assessment. We wouldn't last a year without it, and then we wouldn't make it more than a few months with it.

    I can imagine. I'm pretty sure I see all those mothers on a daily basis as I'm taking my son for a walk in the local mall. I just smile, put my ipod on and keep to myself.
  • jason
    While I'm sure you haven't been drinking...how long have you been up? J/K I totally agree, the only time I even look at Parenting magazines is when I'm stuck in a doctor's waiting room, and I'm pretty sure that I am not within their target audience...
  • It feels like days :)

    The only thing I do with parenting magazines is flip to the snack and kids food section and clip out ideas to keep for when my son is a little older and I need some healthy and creative snack ideas. They are very good for that.
  • Awesome Idea! Of course you realize that the minute we put out a magazine that is just for guys and parenting it will be looked upon as sexist. (oiy).

    "He just told me to shut the f@%k up and I felt so much better about myself."

    I'd be willing to help out with this wherever possible to get it off the ground!
  • "There's your therapy, mowing the lawn and crying...The Leary kid must be in therapy again, their lawn looks unbelievebable!"

    Yeah, I agree, which is why this idea will work for a while but then get quashed unfortunately. But, hey, we can dream, right?
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: