Inside the mind of a stay-at-home-dad

by PJ Mullen on December 11, 2009

in Book Reviews, Fatherhood Friday, Featured

book There are an increasing number of books coming out written about fatherhood these days. In his book “Daddy, where’s your vagina?” author Joe Schatz breaks down many of the roles and responsibilities that this generation of fathers need to embrace. In this ‘Dad 2.0′ world, as he puts it, fathers are no longer just viewed as ‘hunters and gatherers’, but also nurturers.

Before I get too far into it, I wanted to note that my review needs to be prefaced by the fact that I am very biased. While I did purchase this book with my own money, the topic is very important to me and the author has been a big influence to me both as a blogger and a stay at home dad.

For those of you not visiting from Dad-Blogs, Joe, who initially started writing about his adventures as a SAHD on his blog Joeprah, is the co-founder of Dad-Blogs, a great community for dads (and moms) where I’ve met a lot of great people and also write a column. When I first learned that Joe was writing a book about his experience as a stay at home dad I was eager to read it to see what information I could glean from him.

While I’ve been a stay at home dad for over a year and a half now, Joe has over nine years and three children under his belt. Despite the fact that I know a good bit about Joe from his blog and our interactions, I was confident that there would be some takeaways that could help me be a better father to my son.

As I began reading the book I appreciated the way it was organized in that it is broken down into a number of tightly written chapters. There are some great nuggets of wisdom and the book’s structure enables you to quickly refer back to specific topics as you need them.

Throughout the book Joe has managed to create a nice balance of personal reflections on adjusting to life as a stay at home dad, helpful information for parents and humorous anecdotes about his family life. He touches on a range of topics from the hit the male ego takes while fulfilling this nontraditional role to the impact of a miscarriage.

One of my favorite parts of the book comes in the chapter ‘The Problem With Male Pride’ when he discusses the topic of money. Obviously being the one who stayed at home with his daughter he wasn’t earning a paycheck. Despite the value his work was to his household, the idea that his wife was bringing home all of ‘their’ money created a sense of guilt to which I totally related.

Overall the book is a fast, entertaining read that will not only leave you with some great information, but will make you laugh with the tales he spins. I would certainly recommend it for a new dad, regardless of whether or not they are to be the at home parent. It is also a great read for anyone that wants to understand the internal struggles that a stay at home dad deals with, be it a friend or family member that wants to be supportive.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
  • SO excited for my SIGNED copy to arrive...YEAH ME!
  • Nice! That's pretty sweet. I found a typo in mine, so Joe tells me that makes it a limited edition :)
  • HAHAHA. I'm so glad I didn't get drummed out of town for my comment. I read Ron's assessment, and I think he's right. If there's one thing I hate it's lecturing. Being a SAHD I've gotten so much unsolicited advice from people who assume I'm a novice that I no longer listen. Unfortunately most of the criticism comes from women, who you'd think would be more sensitive to feeling second class (considering sexism and all) -- but, not many are. Joe says this book talks to dads without lecturing. In that case I'm interested. And, Joe, I don't mean to be the grinch about your book. That accomplishment in itself is balls! I resolve to read it THEN formulate an opinion :-) Hows that?
  • No way man, dissent can be a good thing. I definitely feel you with the condescending advice you get from people (unfortunately mostly women) who should mind their own business or assume too much. A lot of the advice might be common sense, but there is some good stuff. I read it because I was more interested in filling in the gaps on his story and what I knew about him from his blog and Dad Blogs. That made it more valuable for me. Obviously your mileage may vary and you may stick to your opinion, which, again, is totally cool.
  • PJ - great review, and great discussion in the comments. You kicked off something that was rattling around my brain as I read Joe's book: I wonder how dads feel about getting all these parenting books that take them through child care like a maintenance manual for a car? DadLabs is one example. I mean, I thought it was useful and all, but there was no connection and I found it easy to put down and walk away from. I wonder if dads get so much step-by-step instruction from mommy that to get more of it from a book makes them tune it out easier?
  • Ha! Love the car manual reference. With the DadLabs book it came out so far after I needed something like it that I skipped most of the detailed stuff and looked for the funny parts. And it is very possible that if they are being inundated with information from the mother that they will tune out anything else. I'm fortunate that my wife was not like that, as she realized we were both learning on the job. We did a fair job of sharing what we found worked and didn't work when our son was younger. If she had tried to tell me what to do all the time I might have tuned her out too :)
  • On my wish list. I'm sure I will at least get some book gift cards I can pick it up with.
  • Cool, you'll have to let me know what you think.
  • I'm looking forward to reading Joe's book. I think that even as a working father, the role of fathers has changed and also is being recognized by many as an important part of the family. Embracing the care that fathers provide is part of the key to understanding how essential fatherhood is in a child's life. Can't wait to read it- thanks for sharing your review.
  • No problem man, while he wrote about his experience as a SAHD that is just part of it. There is some 'friendly advice', but not the preachy kind you'd get from the 'expert' types.
  • No problem man, while he wrote about his experience as a SAHD that is just part of it. There is some 'friendly advice', but not the preachy kind you'd get from the 'expert' types.
  • theteachertom
    I've never read a parenting book in my life -- I live within 15 minutes of both my mother and mother-in-law who pretty much taught me everything I know -- but you've persuaded me this would be a worthwhile read.

    I never felt the male ego money thing. I married my boss. =)
  • Unfortunately I know that money and ego thing all too well. It has gotten better, especially after we decided to not exchange gifts for holidays. I've tried to limit my exposure to parenting books, as the ones I've skimmed can be very contradictory. Joe's reads like a conversation amongst friends.
  • Clearly, SAHM and SAHD are bothered and moved by the same exact things, when parenting our children. Except, you know, you guys don't have to deal with Aunt Flo...on a real personal level, I mean...ya' know?!?
  • HAHAHAHAHA! Yeah, we just have to deal with gas, but that is usually self inflicted from watching football and eating nachos :)
  • ciaraj
    great review, pj. if i had the extra $$ right now, i'd definitely buy joe's book.
  • Thank you, hopefully you'll win a copy...autographed no less :)
  • Joe
    Dude, what a fantastic review. Seriously man, I am absolutely humbled. Thanks so much for taking the time, remind me to buy you a beer when we finally get together.

    @ Keith I totally agree with you comment and I actually hate being preached to. I kept that in mind when I wrote the book so it would come across more like a friend talking to another friend rather than an expert spouting advice from up on high--because seriously, who could ever be an expert when it comes to babies peeing on us? I think you would be a great person to review the book just because you are such a cynic. I won't even slap you.
  • You're welcome. Glad to spread the word. You owe me nothing, I probably still owe you.
  • I have to admit, I'm not a big fan of parenting books. Unless they are scientifically based all I see is random babbling about some random person's life which doesn't really matter to me. I know, I know, it sounds terrible. Blogs are different for me. I like blogs because they connect a community of people who are all talking together. When I read parenting books I almost always feel like I'm being lectured to, and I hate that. Maybe I shouldn't be such a downer, but I just had to spout what I think of parenting books in general. OK, everyone can slap my now for being so anti-social! :-)
  • Ordinarily I'd agree with you, as I'm not fan of parenting books either. The only two books I've read cover to cover were the DadLabs' book and Joe's. The other parenting books by the "experts" I basically skimmed or watched them collect dust on a shelf. Most of it is all common sense.

    I do agree that because books are one sided that they can be 'preachy', but coming from a fellow dad blogger his book filled in some gaps for me. Also, after having read the book I know that I could interact with him on his blog with any followup. The better argument is that if more books about parenting started out as blogs and developed a community first they could be more useful than the otherwise doorstop material they've become.
  • I salute you, Joe, and all the stay at home dads. It is a job that is way too hard for me.
  • I don't know how he does it with three kids. I'm drowning with one.
  • I'm ordering this for myself and a friend (new dad) for Christmas. Looking forward to it.
  • Very cool, I'm sure he'll appreciate it.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: